Bathtub Liners vs. Full Bath Replacement

When an existing bathtub starts to show noticeable signs of wear and tear, loses its functionality, and looks outdated, most homeowners are faced with the challenge of making the right decision. Which should it be – bathtub liner or refinishing, or maybe complete bathtub replacement? Today, we’ll talk about the pros and cons of installing each available solution so that you can pick the better option that covers the everyday needs of your family, suits your budget, and adds to the practicality and aesthetics of your bathroom.

Bathtub Liners

A tub liner is a type of custom-made acrylic coating for your old tub. Usually, these are high-quality and low-maintenance acrylic liners or PVC liners perfect for a budget-friendly bathroom makeover.

Features, Installation Process, Price

Bathtub liners are made from high-quality, non-porous material that prevents mold and mildew. They come in a variety of colors so that you can easily fit them into your bathroom décor. There are different liner types you can choose from; no matter if you decide to update a traditional tub, a freestanding one, or a walk-in model, there is an option for every purpose.

Installing a bathtub liner does not take long. Usually, the existing surface is professionally installed in less than a day. However, since it is a custom-made solution, the measurements and production may take a while, depending on your personal needs and preferences.

The cost of bathtub liners varies between $1300 and $4300, depending on the materials used, size, and additional service.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Bathtub liners come with a set of advantages and drawbacks that you must consider before you choose to install them. They are the following:

• Advantages
  • Lasting and durable finish.
  • More economical solution than a full replacement.
  • Minimal disruption to your household and fast installation.
• Disadvantages
  • Failed liners lead to moisture build-up and mildew problems.

When Is A Bath Liner the Best Solution?

Installing a liner would be a great option for many homeowners who are looking for a swift, cost-effective, and efficient way to upgrade a worn-out bathtub. However, the solution is functional as long as your old tub is in a good structural state. Bathtubs that leak, have serious cracks, and cause other significant damage should be replaced entirely.

Bathtub Refinishing

Refinishing is a process of applying the new coating over the surface of your existing tub to get rid of hard water stains and other minor types of damage. It is a quick and pretty inexpensive way to remodel your bathroom in less than a day.

Features, Installation Process, Price

Refinishing works on most types of baths, including but not limited to fiberglass, acrylic, and porcelain tubs. Although the process itself is relatively hassle-free, it takes proper surface preparation for the glazing to last longer. Trained contractors take time to repair and clean the tub before applying the coating.

Refinishing is an excellent choice if you want to update your bathtub and spice things up with a new color. There are custom shades available. Overall, refinishing is the cheapest of all since the cost varies between $300 and $600 per piece. However, the coating’s longevity is pretty limited. In some cases, it lasts from three to five years, especially if the bathtub isn’t adequately maintained.

Pros and Cons

• Pros
  • Affordability.
  • Swift installation.
  • Flexibility.
• Cons
  • Longevity.

In What Cases and to Whom Is It Best for?

If your old tub is only visually workable and the structure is still sound and reliable, a cosmetic upgrade is what you need and what refinishing initially implies. It is an effortless and economical approach to bathroom remodeling.

Bathtub Replacement

Bathtub replacement is the comprehensive process of removing the existing bath and changing it for a new tub. When you initiate the replacement process, you can work on the plumbing, tiling, and walls at the same time. If you are in for a complete bathroom revamping, tub replacement is your go-to solution.

Features, Installation Process, Price

New tubs come in a variety of shapes, colors, and forms. You can choose to install a unique bathtub made of cast iron, steel, fiberglass, or any other material in a preferred shade that reflects your taste and complements the interior.

Replacing a bathtub implies complete removal of the original tub, which makes it longer and more complicated. At times, installing a new bathtub requires plumbing adjustments and other necessary fixtures.

The scope of demolition works, new tub price, and installation costs vary, but you can expect to invest from $1500 to over $5000 into the remodeling.

Benefits and Drawbacks

• Benefits
  • Increased property value
  • Improved aesthetic appeal
  • Enhanced functionality
  • Extended lifespan
• Drawbacks
  • Costly investment
  • Potential additional expenses may arise
  • Longer installation process

In What Cases and to Whom Is It Best for?

If you have been postponing full-scale bathroom revamping for a while and your existing tub starts to leak or fails to meet your current needs – it is high time to consider bathtub replacement.

Comparison Table: Bathtub Liners vs. Refinishing vs. Replacement

Summary and Checklist for Your Selection

There is more than a single factor to evaluate when picking between bathtub liners, professional refinishing, or total replacement. We’ll try to point you in the right direction using a simple checklist:

• Condition
  • Cracks, chips, stains – liners or bathtub refinishing
  • Leaks and major structural damage – bathtub replacement
• Budget
  • Low budget – bathtub refinishing
  • Medium budget – bathtub liners
  • High budget – replacement
• Longevity
  • Temporary fixtures – bathtub refinishing
  • Lasting or permanent fixtures – bathtub liners or replacement
• Renovation Plans
  • Non-invasive remodeling – refinishing or bathtub liners
  • Invasive remodeling – tub replacement

Still Need Professional Help?

Making the right choice is always a daunting experience. The moment you start to feel like your existing tub begins to fail your expectations and turns a relaxing experience into buyer’s remorse, let us know!

You can contact us online or give us a quick call, and one of our agents will come over for a free in-house consultation. Our professionals understand all the nuances of the bathroom remodeling process so that they can advise you on the best solution. We prioritize your needs, value your preferences, and deliver quality craftsmanship that will serve you for years to come.